Tuesday, April 1, 2008 - 11:25 AM

Comparison of Four Fuel Cell Battery Hybrid Powertrains in Bus Applications

Kevin Harris, Hydrogenics Corporation

Over the years, buses have provided an excellent platform to test and demonstrate the capabilities and benefits of hydrogen fuel cell technology. There are multiple technology drivers of powering buses with fuel cells which include the need to improve urban air quality, increase energy independence, mitigate climate change, and minimize noise. Yet certain barriers to meaningful commercialization still exist, namely cost of acquisition, and durability (lifetime) which leads to high maintenance costs.

 In order to determine the preferred commercialization pathway for buses, Hydrogenics has been involved with four different fuel cell hybrid bus projects ranging from fuel cell dominant to battery dominant. The various architectures of this range of fuel cell hybrid power trains are discussed, along with the respective global demonstrations that have taken place, or will take place, in Hawaii, Manitoba, and North-Rhine Westphalia (Germany), Alabama, South Carolina, Connecticut, and Burbank. Experiences and anticipated outcomes of each project are discussed.

 To date, Hydrogenics’ experience has indicated that buses with smaller fuel cells show significantly lower upfront costs, with promise of lower operating and maintenance costs.  In one scenario, the anticipated lifecycle costs of a fuel cell battery dominant hybrid bus are shown to be less than that of a conventional diesel bus.